Myths and Facts About Wood Finishing

Wood finishing is an art that requires knowledge, skill, and an understanding of the materials involved. However, there are many myths and misconceptions surrounding this topic. In this article, we will debunk common myths and present facts about wood finishing, providing valuable tips, techniques, and best practices.

One of the most common misconceptions is that varnish and stain are interchangeable. The truth is that varnish is a transparent protective finish, while stain is used to enhance the color of the wood. Understanding the difference between these two products is crucial for achieving the desired results in your wood finishing projects.

Another myth is that wood finishing is a complicated process that requires expensive tools and materials. While there are advanced techniques and high-end products available, it is possible to achieve excellent results with basic tools and affordable finishes. Learning the fundamentals and following best practices can go a long way in achieving professional-looking results.

It is also important to address the misconception that all wood species require the same finishing techniques. Different woods have distinct characteristics and may require specific approaches to achieve the desired outcome. Understanding the properties of the wood you are working with is essential for successful wood finishing.

Throughout this article, we will explore these myths and more, providing you with accurate information, debunking misconceptions, and highlighting the best practices for wood finishing. By the end, you will have a better understanding of this art form and the knowledge to achieve beautiful, long-lasting results in your wood projects.

Myth: Kiln dry lumber means dry lumber

Contrary to popular belief, kiln-dried lumber does not necessarily mean that the wood is completely dry. Wood can still shrink and swell in response to moisture and relative humidity below its fiber saturation point. It is crucial to understand the moisture content of the lumber when purchasing and using it for various applications. Properly matching the moisture content of the wood with its intended use is essential for preventing problems like warping, rot, and cracks.

Moisture Content and Wood Swelling/Shrinking

Moisture content refers to the amount of water present in wood, usually expressed as a percentage of the wood’s oven-dry weight. Kiln-drying is a common method used to reduce the moisture content of lumber for increased stability and improved workability. However, even kiln-dried lumber retains a certain amount of moisture unless it is stored in a controlled environment.

Wood has the ability to absorb or release moisture from the surrounding environment, causing it to swell or shrink. This moisture-related dimensional change can lead to structural issues and aesthetic problems with wood products. For example, if wood with a high moisture content is used in a dry indoor environment, it will lose moisture and shrink, potentially causing gaps or cracks. On the other hand, if wood with a low moisture content is exposed to a high-humidity environment, it will absorb moisture and swell, leading to warping or distortion.

Moisture Level Effects on Wood
Below Fiber Saturation Point Wood will shrink or swell in response to changes in relative humidity.
Above Fiber Saturation Point Wood will not shrink or swell significantly.

Therefore, it is crucial to consider the moisture content of lumber when purchasing and using it. The appropriate moisture content will depend on the specific application and environmental conditions. By properly acclimating the wood to its intended environment and ensuring its moisture content is suitable, you can minimize the negative effects of swelling and shrinking, ensuring the longevity and performance of wood products.

Myth: Cedar and redwood are rot resistant.

When it comes to wood durability, cedar and redwood are often praised for their natural rot resistance. However, it’s important to distinguish between the heartwood and sapwood of these species. While the heartwood of cedar and redwood does possess natural decay resistance, the sapwood, which comprises a significant portion of harvested lumber, lacks this quality.

To ensure the highest level of rot resistance in cedar and redwood, it is advisable to specify all-heartwood lumber for your projects. This will ensure that the wood is inherently more resistant to decay and will help prevent issues such as fungal rot and wood deterioration over time.

Additionally, treating cedar and redwood with a water repellent can further enhance their rot resistance. Water repellent treatments create a barrier on the wood surface that reduces moisture absorption and helps maintain the dimensional stability of the wood when exposed to the weather. With proper selection of heartwood lumber and the application of water repellent, you can maximize the rot resistance of cedar and redwood in your projects.

Table: Heartwood vs. Sapwood Characteristics

Wood Type Heartwood Sapwood
Cedar Naturally rot resistant Little to no decay resistance
Redwood Naturally rot resistant Little to no decay resistance

As shown in the table above, the heartwood of both cedar and redwood offers natural rot resistance, while the sapwood lacks this quality. Therefore, it is crucial to consider the specific wood type and select all-heartwood lumber when rot resistance is a priority for your project.

Myth: A deck built with pressure-treated wood will last a long time.

One common misconception is that a deck constructed with pressure-treated wood will automatically have a long lifespan. While pressure-treated wood is indeed rot-resistant, it is still susceptible to moisture absorption and subsequent wood movement. This means that even with pressure-treated decking materials, cracks, twisting, and other forms of damage can still occur over time.

To maximize the longevity of a pressure-treated wood deck, proper installation and regular maintenance are essential. Applying a water repellent treatment can help mitigate wood movement and maintain the appearance and structural integrity of the deck. Additionally, using corrosion-resistant screws and regularly reapplying a water repellent finish can further protect the wood from moisture penetration.

Table: Comparing the Longevity Factors of Pressure-Treated Wood Decks

Factors Potential Impact on Deck Longevity
Proper installation Ensures structural stability
Regular maintenance Prevents wood damage and decay
Water repellent treatment Reduces moisture absorption and wood movement
Corrosion-resistant screws Avoids rusting and weakening of fasteners
Yearly reapplication of water repellent Sustains long-term protection against moisture

By considering these factors and taking appropriate measures, homeowners can ensure that their pressure-treated wood decks remain sturdy and visually appealing for many years to come.

Overall, while pressure-treated wood is a popular choice for decking due to its rot-resistant properties, it is important to understand that proper installation and maintenance are crucial for maximizing the lifespan of a deck. By following best practices and regularly maintaining the deck, homeowners can confidently enjoy their pressure-treated wood deck for an extended period.

Myth: Hardwoods are hard, softwoods are soft

Many people believe that hardwoods are hard and softwoods are soft based on their names. However, this is a common misconception. The terms “hardwood” and “softwood” actually refer to the type of tree the wood comes from, rather than its hardness or softness. In reality, wood density is the primary factor that determines the hardness and strength of a particular species.

Wood density is typically measured using a metric called specific gravity. Specific gravity represents the ratio of the density of wood to the density of water. It provides valuable information about the weight, strength, and workability of different wood species. While it is true that certain hardwoods like oak or hickory are typically denser and harder than softwoods like pine or cedar, there are exceptions to this generalization. Some softwoods, such as yew or balsa, can have lower densities than certain hardwoods.

To work effectively with different wood species, it is essential to consider their specific gravity and understand how it impacts various woodworking processes. Density influences the cutting, machining, and fastening properties of wood, as well as its dimensional stability. For example, denser hardwoods may require more powerful cutting tools and stronger fasteners to work with effectively. Softwoods with lower specific gravity may be easier to cut and shape but may also be more prone to denting or crushing if not handled carefully.

Myth: Dry rot is a type of rot

Dry rot is a term often misunderstood when it comes to wood decay. Contrary to its name, dry rot does not occur in wood that is completely dry. Wood needs moisture to decay, and the name “dry rot” stems from the fact that the affected wood appears dry when the decay is discovered. However, there is always a source of moisture that contributes to the rot, which needs to be fixed to prevent further damage.

Preventing dry rot starts by keeping the moisture content of wood below a certain threshold, typically around 20%. This can be achieved by addressing water leaks, improving ventilation, and controlling humidity levels. Regular inspections and maintenance of wooden structures, such as decks, fences, and siding, can help detect and address moisture-related issues before they lead to dry rot.

By understanding that dry rot is not a type of rot but rather a result of excessive moisture, homeowners can take the necessary precautions to protect their wood from decay. Keeping wood dry and addressing any sources of moisture will help maintain its structural integrity and prolong its lifespan.

Myth: Rot is contagious.

Contrary to popular belief, rot is not contagious in the sense that it can spread from one piece of wood to another. Rot fungi are present everywhere, and wood is exposed to the fungi’s spores at all times. However, for rot to occur, the moisture content needs to be above a certain threshold. Wood with a moisture content below this threshold remains dormant and harmless until the moisture level rises again.

Infection of rot in wood is not a result of contact with already infected wood, but rather a consequence of prolonged exposure to excessive moisture or high humidity levels. The presence of rot fungi spores alone does not cause rot. It is the combination of spores, suitable environmental conditions, and elevated moisture levels that create an environment conducive to rot development.

To prevent or stop rot, it is crucial to control the moisture content of wood and eliminate excessive moisture sources. Properly sealing and maintaining wood surfaces, installing adequate ventilation, and addressing any water leaks or condensation issues can effectively prevent the onset and spread of rot. Ensuring the wood remains dry and moisture-free is key to preserving its structural integrity and preventing the growth of rot fungi.

Common Misconceptions about Wood Rot The Truth
Rot can spread from one piece of wood to another. Rot is not contagious and does not spread between wood pieces.
Mere contact with infected wood can cause rot. Rot requires prolonged exposure to excessive moisture for development.
Presence of rot fungi spores alone leads to rot. Moisture content above a certain threshold is necessary for rot to occur.
Wood with dormant rot fungi can cause infections. Wood remains harmless if its moisture content is kept below the threshold.

By understanding these facts and dispelling the myth of contagious rot, homeowners, builders, and anyone working with wood can take appropriate measures to prevent rot and protect their structures from unnecessary damage and decay.

Myth: Shellac is outdated.

Shellac is often considered an old-fashioned finish, but it is an all-natural, organic, and child-safe option. Contrary to the misconception that shellac turns ugly and dark with age, it is naturally UV-resistant and can maintain its clarity over time. Additionally, shellac is compatible with various other finishes and can be used to make a universal sanding sealer for wood projects.

One of the myths surrounding shellac is that it is not as durable as modern finishes. While it is true that shellac is not as resistant to water and heat as some other finishes, it still provides adequate protection for most indoor wood projects. Shellac is especially suitable for furniture, cabinets, and interior trim.

Shellac is easy to apply and dries quickly, allowing for multiple coats in a shorter timeframe. It can be applied with a brush, pad, or spray gun, and it lends a beautiful, warm glow to the wood. Shellac also has the advantage of being easy to repair, as it can be spot-treated or recoated without the need for extensive sanding or stripping.

Debunking Common Shellac Myths

Myth Fact
Shellac turns yellow over time. Shellac naturally maintains its clarity and does not yellow with age.
Shellac is not as durable as other finishes. While not as resistant to water and heat, shellac provides adequate protection for most indoor wood projects.
Shellac is difficult to apply and repair. Shellac is easy to apply, dries quickly, and can be spot-treated or recoated without extensive sanding or stripping.

Myth: Waxing hardwood floors is necessary.

One common myth about hardwood floors is the belief that waxing is necessary for their maintenance. However, this is no longer the case with modern hardwood floor finishes. Waxing hardwood floors was once a common practice used to add shine and protection to the surface. However, advancements in floor finishes have made waxing unnecessary and can even be detrimental to the longevity and appearance of the floors.

Today’s hardwood floor finishes are designed to be durable and long-lasting, providing ample protection against daily wear and tear. These finishes create a protective barrier that prevents dirt, spills, and stains from penetrating the wood. Regular cleaning and proper maintenance, such as sweeping or vacuuming regularly and promptly cleaning up spills, are sufficient for keeping hardwood floors in top condition.

Waxing hardwood floors can actually hinder the application of a fresh coat of finish when needed. The wax buildup needs to be completely removed before applying a new finish, which can be time-consuming and labor-intensive. Additionally, waxed floors can become slippery, posing a risk of falls. Therefore, it is best to avoid waxing hardwood floors and instead focus on regular cleaning and proper maintenance to preserve their beauty and longevity.

Table: Pros and Cons of Waxing Hardwood Floors

Pros Cons
Provides shine Requires regular stripping
Creates a barrier against moisture Can be slippery
Can mask minor scratches May attract dust and dirt
Can hinder the application of a fresh coat of finish

What are some common myths about wood finishes, and what are the facts?

Many people believe that oil-based finishes are the best finish for cherry wood, but in fact, water-based finishes can also be a great choice. Another popular myth is that more coats will result in a better finish, when in reality, one or two coats may be sufficient for cherry wood.

Myth: Refinishing hardwood floors is a good DIY project.

While refinishing hardwood floors may seem like a tempting DIY project, it is important to consider the potential challenges and risks involved. Professional refinishing offers several advantages over a DIY approach, ensuring optimal results and long-lasting finishes.

Firstly, professional-grade equipment is key to achieving a smooth and even surface. Sanding hardwood floors requires specialized machinery that can efficiently remove old finishes and imperfections, while minimizing wood loss. This level of precision is difficult to achieve with consumer-grade tools.

Expertise is another crucial factor in achieving a successful refinishing job.

Professionals have the necessary knowledge and experience to assess the condition of the floors, identify any underlying issues, and apply the appropriate refinishing techniques. They can handle potential challenges, such as floor repairs, uneven surfaces, or color matching, ensuring a seamless and beautiful result.

Furthermore, professionals have access to high-quality finishes that are not typically available to consumers. These finishes are specifically formulated to provide superior durability, protection, and long-lasting beauty. DIY finishes may not offer the same level of performance and may require more frequent maintenance and recoating.

In summary, while DIY projects can be fulfilling, refinishing hardwood floors is best left to the professionals. Their expertise, specialized equipment, and access to high-quality finishes ensure a superior result that will stand the test of time. Investing in professional refinishing guarantees a beautiful and long-lasting transformation for your hardwood floors.

Scroll to Top